📘 Appeal to the Supreme Court: A Student-Friendly Guide 🎓📚⚖️

✎ What Is an Appeal? 🤔📜🔍

An appeal is when a person who is unhappy with a court’s decision asks a higher court to review and possibly change it. In India, appeals to the Supreme Court can be made through the Constitution or under a law called the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC), 1908. 🏛️📝⚖️

🏛️ Appeals Under the Constitution 📖🔺📘

• Article 132: Appeals on Constitutional Questions

• Applies when a case involves a serious question about the Constitution.

• The High Court must certify that the case fits this rule.

• Example Case: Durga Shankar Mehta v. Raghuraj Singh (1954).

• Article 133: Civil Appeals

• For civil disputes (like property or contracts).

• The case must involve a major legal issue.

• The High Court must allow the appeal.

• Since 1972, no minimum money limit is needed.

• Example Case: Kesoram Industries Ltd. v. Commissioner of Wealth Tax (1966).

• Article 134: Criminal Appeals

• For criminal matters.

• You can appeal if:

  • The High Court reverses an acquittal and gives a death sentence.

  • The High Court certifies the case as important.

• Example Case: Pritam Singh v. State (1950).

• Article 136: Special Leave Petition (SLP)

• The Supreme Court can allow an appeal from any court or tribunal (except military courts).

• This is not a right—it’s up to the Court.

• Example Cases: DCM v. CIT (1955), Kunhayammed v. State of Kerala (2000).

• Article 137: Review Power

• The Supreme Court can review and change its own judgment in special cases. 🔁⚖️📄

📜 Appeals Under the CPC 📚🧾🧑‍⚖️

• Section 109 CPC

• A person can appeal a High Court ruling if it involves a serious legal issue and the High Court gives permission.

• Section 112 CPC

• Makes it clear that CPC rules do not override Constitutional rights. ⚖️📌📕

⚖️ Comparing Appeals Under Constitution vs CPC 🧮📋📘

🔍 Common Reasons for Appeal ⚠️📑👁️

• Legal error by lower court.

• Violation of natural justice (e.g., no fair hearing).

• Ignored important evidence.

• Wrong application of law. 🧠📉📎

📝 How to File an Appeal to the Supreme Court 🧾🧑‍⚖️📤

Steps:

1. Get High Court certification (if needed).

2. Hire an Advocate-on-Record to draft the petition.

3. Prepare required documents:

   • Copy of the judgment.

   • Affidavit and vakalatnama.

   • Pay court fees.

4. File the appeal (online or offline).

5. Respect the time limits:

   • 90 days for regular appeals (Arts. 132–134).

   • 60 days for SLP (Art. 136).

6. Delay? The court may allow it with a good reason. ⏳📬🛂

📂 Can You Show New Evidence? 📎📉🧐

• Normally, no.

• But under Order XLI Rule 27 CPC, new evidence is allowed if:

  • The trial court unfairly stopped it.

  • It’s essential for justice. 📁⚖️📌

📚 Important Case Laws 🏛️🧠📘

• Mathai @ Joby v. George (2010): SLP is not a right—only in rare cases.

• Kunhayammed v. State of Kerala (2000): Effects of SLP dismissal explained.

• Union of India v. B.N. Anantharam (2020): Stressed careful review in SLPs. 📝🔍⚖️

🧭 Appeal Journey in Civil Cases 🛤️🗂️👨‍⚖️

Trial Court ➔ First Appeal ➔ Second Appeal ➔ Supreme Court Appeal (Arts. 132/133/136) 🧷📘➡️

📘 Exam Corner 🎓🧠📖

Possible Questions:

• How do appeals to the Supreme Court work?

• What is the difference between a regular appeal and an SLP?

• When can an SLP be filed?

Study Tip: Use case examples, flowcharts, and tables to make long answers more effective. 🗒️✅💡

🗿 Conclusion 🏁📜🔍

Appeals to the Supreme Court are a way to ensure fairness and correct serious legal mistakes. But not all cases can go to the Supreme Court—it only hears cases involving major legal or constitutional issues. 🧑‍⚖️📌⚠️