CPC Notes

Production, Impounding and Return of Documents under the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908

1. Introduction

Documents play an important role in civil proceedings because they help parties establish their respective claims and defences. The Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC) contains specific provisions governing the production, admission, rejection, impounding and return of documents during a civil suit.

The principal provisions are contained in Order XIII, Rules 1–11 CPC, which regulate the production and judicial handling of documents. These provisions aim to ensure that relevant documents are placed before the court at the appropriate stage, irrelevant or inadmissible documents are excluded, and documents received in evidence are properly recorded and preserved.

The object of these provisions is to facilitate a fair and efficient trial by preventing unnecessary delay, avoiding the suppression of material documents and maintaining the proper record of documentary evidence.

FC FACTUALCODE

2.Relevant Provisions

Important provisions governing the production, impounding and return of documents under the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.

Provision Subject
Section 30 CPC Power of the court to order discovery, production and inspection of documents
Order VII Rule 14 Production of documents relied upon by the plaintiff
Order VIII Rule 1A Production of documents relied upon by the defendant
Order XIII Rule 1 Original documents to be produced
Order XIII Rule 2 Omitted Omitted
Order XIII Rule 3 Rejection of irrelevant or inadmissible documents
Order XIII Rules 4–7 Endorsements and recording of documents
Order XIII Rule 8 Impounding of documents
Order XIII Rule 9 Return of admitted documents
Order XIII Rule 10 Calling for records from other courts or the court's own records
Order XIII Rule 11 Application of the rules to material objects

3. Production of Original Documents – Order XIII Rule 1

The production of documentary evidence before the settlement of issues is closely connected with the process of framing of issues, as the court identifies the disputed questions requiring adjudication. 

Before the production of documents at trial, parties may also use the procedural mechanism of discovery and inspection of documents under Order XI CPC to obtain access to relevant documents in the possession or control of the opposite party.

Order XIII Rule 1 provides that the parties or their pleaders shall produce, on or before the settlement of issues, all the documentary evidence in original form which has been filed along with the plaint or written statement.

The rule also permits the court to receive documents at a later stage where they are required for cross-examination of a witness of the other party or where a witness is required to refresh their memory.

The purpose of this provision is to ensure that documentary evidence is produced at an early stage so that the parties and the court can identify the documents on which the dispute is to be decided.

The production of documents at the pleading stage is also governed by Order VII Rule 14 in the case of a plaintiff and Order VIII Rule 1A in the case of a defendant. These provisions deal with documents relied upon by the respective parties and their disclosure with the pleadings.

It is important to distinguish the initial disclosure or filing of documents from their subsequent production in original form under Order XIII Rule 1.

Order XIII Rule 2 has been omitted by the Code of Civil Procedure (Amendment) Act, 1999, with effect from 1 July 2002. Therefore, the former provision concerning the effect of non-production of documents at the appropriate stage should not be treated as an existing rule.

4. Rejection of Irrelevant or Inadmissible Documents – Order XIII Rule 3

Order XIII Rule 3 empowers the court to reject any document which it considers irrelevant or otherwise inadmissible in evidence. The court may exercise this power at any stage of the suit, and the grounds for rejection must be recorded.

A document may be irrelevant where it has no connection with the matters in controversy. It may be inadmissible where a rule of law prevents the court from receiving it in evidence.

For example, a document having no bearing on the disputed transaction may be rejected as irrelevant. Similarly, a document that cannot be admitted because of a statutory bar may be rejected as inadmissible.

The rule prevents unnecessary documents from becoming part of the evidentiary record and helps the court concentrate on the actual matters in dispute.

5. Endorsements on Documents Admitted in Evidence – Order XIII Rule 4

Order XIII Rule 4 requires the court to make certain endorsements on every document admitted in evidence. The endorsement must contain:

  1. The suit number and title of the suit.

  2. The name of the person producing the document.

  3. The date on which the document was produced.

  4. A statement that the document has been admitted in evidence.

  5. The signature or initials of the Judge.

Where a document is admitted in evidence, these endorsements help identify the document and establish its connection with the particular judicial proceeding.

The purpose is to maintain an accurate record and prevent confusion regarding the identity and status of documents produced during the trial.

6. Endorsements on Copies of Entries – Order XIII Rule 5

Order XIII Rule 5 deals with copies of entries in books, accounts or records which are produced in evidence.

Where a copy of an entry is admitted, the court must make an endorsement on it in accordance with the requirements of the rule. The endorsement records the necessary particulars, including the fact of admission and the production of the relevant original record.

This provision is particularly useful where the original consists of books, accounts or records containing several entries, and only particular entries are relevant to the dispute.

The rule helps preserve the evidentiary value and identity of the relevant entries without unnecessarily retaining the entire original record.

7. Endorsements on Documents Rejected – Order XIII Rule 6

Order XIII Rule 6 provides that where a document is rejected as inadmissible in evidence, the court must make an endorsement stating that the document has been rejected and recording the grounds of rejection.

The endorsement must be signed or initialled by the Judge.

This requirement is important because it distinguishes documents admitted in evidence from those rejected by the court. It also preserves a record of the court’s decision and the reasons for excluding a document.

8. Recording of Admitted and Return of Rejected Documents – Order XIII Rule 7

Order XIII Rule 7 deals with the recording and custody of documents after their admission or rejection.

Documents admitted in evidence, including copies where applicable, are included in the record of the suit. Documents which are rejected as inadmissible do not form part of the evidentiary record and must be returned to the persons who produced them.

The distinction is significant because a rejected document cannot be treated as evidence merely because it was presented before the court.

The provision ensures proper maintenance of the judicial record and prevents confusion about the documents that have actually been admitted in evidence.

9. Impounding of Documents – Order XIII Rule 8

Order XIII Rule 8 empowers the court to impound any document where it considers that there is sufficient cause to do so.

When a document is impounded, it is retained in the custody of an officer of the court, subject to such conditions and for such period as the court considers appropriate.

Impounding is a discretionary power and should be exercised for sufficient reasons. It may be necessary where the preservation of a document is important for the proper adjudication of the dispute or where its custody must be secured.

It should be noted that impounding under Order XIII Rule 8 is distinct from the power to impound insufficiently stamped instruments under Section 33 of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899, which operates under a separate statutory framework.

10. Return of Admitted Documents – Order XIII Rule 9

Order XIII Rule 9 provides for the return of documents admitted in evidence after the conclusion of the proceedings, subject to the conditions prescribed by the rule.

Where no appeal is allowed, the documents may ordinarily be returned after the disposal of the suit. Where an appeal is allowed, they may be returned after the period for filing the appeal has expired without an appeal being filed, or after the appeal has been disposed of.

The proviso permits the court to return an admitted document earlier where the prescribed conditions are satisfied. Generally, the applicant must furnish a copy to be substituted in the record and undertake to produce the original if required by the court.

The court may provide a certified copy to a party and, where the applicant is not a party, the copy may be examined, compared and certified in accordance with the applicable provisions.

The rule also restricts the return of a document which, by virtue of the decree, has become wholly void or useless. A receipt acknowledging the return of the document must be obtained.

The purpose of this provision is to protect the judicial record while allowing parties to recover their original documents when their continued retention is no longer necessary.

11. Calling for Records from Other Courts – Order XIII Rule 10

Order XIII Rule 10 empowers the court to call for records from its own records or from another court, either on its own motion or upon an application by a party.

Where a party applies for the production of a record from another proceeding, the application should ordinarily be supported by an affidavit explaining the relevance of the record and why a duly authenticated copy cannot be obtained without unreasonable delay or expense, or why the original record is necessary in the interests of justice.

The power is intended to assist the court in obtaining material records necessary for the proper determination of the dispute. However, merely calling for a record does not automatically make every document contained in it admissible in evidence. The ordinary rules of relevancy, admissibility and proof continue to apply.

In Lakshmi v. Chinnammal @ Rayyammal, (2009) 13 SCC 25, the Supreme Court considered the importance of obtaining relevant material from another judicial proceeding. The decision illustrates that the court’s power to call for records may be exercised where the material is necessary for deciding the dispute, rather than being used for an unnecessary or fishing inquiry.

12. Application to Material Objects – Order XIII Rule 11

Order XIII Rule 11 provides that the rules contained in the preceding provisions of the Order shall, so far as may be, apply to material objects produced before the court.

Material objects may include physical articles or other things connected with the dispute. The court may receive, record, preserve or return such objects in an appropriate manner, applying the principles governing documentary evidence wherever applicable.

This provision ensures that the handling of physical evidence is also regulated by procedural safeguards.

13. Important Evidentiary Principles and Modern Developments

A. Marking of a Document and Proof of Its Contents

An important principle of documentary evidence is that merely marking a document as an exhibit does not automatically prove its execution, authenticity or contents.

In Sait Tarajee Khimchand v. Yelamarti Satyam, AIR 1971 SC 1865, the Supreme Court held that:

“The mere marking of an exhibit does not dispense with the proof of documents.”

Therefore, admission of a document as an exhibit and proof of its contents are distinct evidentiary requirements. A party must still establish the document in accordance with the applicable law of evidence.

This distinction is important because the court must consider not merely whether a document has been marked, but whether it has been legally proved and whether it is admissible for the purpose for which it is relied upon.

B. Electronic Records under the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023

With effect from 1 July 2024, the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (BSA) replaced the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, subject to the applicable savings provisions.

Sections 61–63 of the BSA deal with electronic and digital records. Section 63 provides the conditions governing the admissibility of electronic records produced in the manner contemplated by that provision.

Under Section 63(4), a certificate containing the prescribed particulars must accompany the electronic record when it is submitted for admission in evidence under the section. The certificate identifies the electronic record, describes the manner of its production and provides relevant particulars concerning the device and statutory conditions. The Schedule to the BSA contains the prescribed certificate format.

Section 63(4) corresponds functionally to Section 65B(4) of the former Indian Evidence Act, 1872. In Anvar P.V. v. P.K. Basheer, (2014) 10 SCC 473, the Supreme Court interpreted the certificate requirement under Section 65B. The decision remains an important reference for understanding the earlier statutory framework, although the current provision is Section 63 of the BSA. The subsequent decision in Arjun Panditrao Khotkar v. Kailash Kushanrao Gorantyal, (2020) 7 SCC 1, also explained the certificate requirement under the former Act.

Thus, electronic records produced in civil proceedings must be considered in accordance with the applicable provisions of the BSA.

C. Special Rules for Commercial Disputes

The Commercial Courts Act, 2015 introduced a special disclosure and inspection framework for commercial disputes of specified value. Section 16 of that Act provides for amendments to the CPC, including a substituted Order XI applicable to such disputes.

The substituted Order XI requires detailed disclosure of relevant documents, including documents within a party’s possession, power, control or custody. It also regulates admission and denial of documents and restricts reliance on documents that were not disclosed, subject to the court’s permission.

Accordingly, the ordinary procedure under Order XIII must be read alongside the special disclosure and inspection requirements applicable to commercial disputes.

14. Conclusion

Order XIII CPC provides an organised procedure for the production, admission, rejection, impounding and return of documents in civil proceedings. Its provisions ensure that documentary evidence is properly placed before the court, irrelevant or inadmissible documents are excluded, and admitted documents are preserved as part of the judicial record.

The provisions must also be understood alongside the rules governing production of documents with pleadings, the law of evidence relating to proof of documents and the modern requirements governing electronic records. Together, these procedural safeguards promote fairness, accuracy and efficiency in the adjudication of civil disputes.

Responsive Social Media Badges
Scroll to Top