CPC Notes

Order 21 Rule 35 CPC: Execution of Decrees for Possession of Immovable Property

📘 Build Your CPC Foundation

Study Tip: Before learning individual topics such as Issues under Order XIV CPC, it is beneficial to understand the overall structure of the Code of Civil Procedure and the sequence in which a civil suit progresses. These two guides provide the conceptual foundation needed to study every provision of the CPC systematically and confidently.

1.Introduction

A decree for possession of immovable property does not enforce itself. If the judgment-debtor refuses to vacate, or if another person occupies the property, the decree-holder must obtain possession through the executing court. The Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC), therefore prescribes different methods of delivery according to the nature of the decree and the legal status of the occupant.

Order 21 Rule 35 CPC is the principal provision governing delivery of immovable property under a decree. It deals with actual delivery, joint possession and removal of physical obstructions. Order XXI Rule 36 complements it by providing for formal or symbolic delivery where the property is occupied by a tenant or another person entitled to remain in occupation and who is not bound by the decree to relinquish it.

These provisions secure the decree-holder’s relief while protecting persons whose independent rights are not concluded by the decree.

2. Scope and Statutory Framework of Order 21 Rule 35 CPC

Sections 36–74 CPC contain general provisions relating to execution, while Order XXI provides the detailed procedure. Such a decree may arise in a title or possessory suit, a suit following termination of a lease, or other proceedings directing delivery of immovable property.

The executing court must implement the decree as drawn; it cannot reopen its merits or grant inconsistent relief, but may make incidental orders necessary for effective execution. Order 21 Rule 35 contains three distinct sub-rules.

3. Order 21 Rule 35(1): Actual or Physical Delivery

Rule 35(1) provides that where a decree is for delivery of immovable property, possession shall be delivered to the party in whose favour it has been adjudged, or to a person appointed by that party to receive delivery. Where necessary, delivery may be effected by removing any person bound by the decree who refuses to vacate.

This is actual or physical delivery of possession. The court delivers possession to the successful party or an authorised representative and, where necessary, removes the judgment-debtor or another person bound by the decree who refuses to vacate.

The expression “person bound by the decree” may include persons claiming through the judgment-debtor whose rights are subject to it. The rule does not authorise indiscriminate eviction of an occupant asserting an independent right not concluded by the decree.

Judicial Interpretation:

In B. Gangadhar v. B.G. Rajalingam, (1995) 5 SCC 238, the judgment-debtor had constructed shops on the suit property during the litigation and inducted tenants without the court’s permission. The Supreme Court upheld the executing court’s power to direct removal of the constructions and deliver vacant possession.

It held that Rule 35(3), together with the court’s incidental and ancillary powers, enables effective enforcement of a possession decree; the decree-holder need not institute a separate suit merely because the judgment-debtor has created a superstructure pendente lite. The Court also held, on the facts, that tenants inducted through the judgment-debtor during the suit were bound by the decree and could not obstruct its execution.

4. Order 21 Rule 35(2): Delivery of Joint Possession

Rule 35(2) applies where the decree itself awards joint possession of immovable property. The court delivers such possession by:

  1. Affixing a copy of the warrant in a conspicuous place on the property; and

  2. Proclaiming the substance of the decree at a convenient place by beat of drum or another customary mode.

The other co-sharer is not ordinarily removed because the decree grants joint, not exclusive, possession. The proclamation gives notice that the decree-holder has been placed in joint possession.

This formal method must be distinguished from Rule 36. Under Rule 35(2), the mode follows from the nature of the decree for joint possession. Under Rule 36, symbolic delivery is prescribed because the property is occupied by a tenant or other person entitled to occupy it who is not bound by the decree to relinquish that occupancy.

5. Order 21 Rule 35(3): Access to Buildings and Removal of Obstacles

Rule 35(3) applies where possession of a building or enclosure is to be delivered and the person in possession, being bound by the decree, does not afford free access. The court, through its officers, may:

  • Remove or open a lock or bolt;

  • Break open a door; or

  • Perform another act necessary to put the decree-holder in possession.

Before taking such steps, the court must give reasonable warning and provide an opportunity and facility for any woman who, according to the customs of the country, does not appear in public to withdraw. This statutory protection traditionally relates to women observing purdah, sometimes described as pardanashin women.

The power is limited to necessary measures against an occupant bound by the decree. B. Gangadhar also recognises the court’s ancillary power to remove unlawful constructions raised pendente lite where required to effect the decree.

Police Assistance During Execution

Where resistance or violence makes execution impracticable, police aid may also be ordered. In Rahul S. Shah v. Jinendrakumar Gandhi, (2021) 6 SCC 418, the Supreme Court directed that an executing court, upon being satisfied that the decree cannot be executed without police assistance, may direct the concerned police station to assist the officials executing it.

6. Order XXI Rule 36: Symbolic Delivery Where a Tenant Is in Occupation

Rule 36 applies where a decree directs delivery of immovable property occupied by a tenant or another person entitled to occupy it who is not bound by the decree to relinquish that occupancy.

The court must:

  1. Affix a copy of the warrant in a conspicuous place on the property; and

  2. Proclaim to the occupant, by beat of drum or another customary mode, the substance of the decree.

This is known as symbolic or formal possession: the occupant is not physically evicted, but delivery is effected through the prescribed formalities. Rule 36 protects an occupant whose right to remain has not been displaced by the decree.

Important Judicial Decision:

In Ratan Lal Jain v. Uma Shankar Vyas, (2002) 2 SCC 656, the owners had leased land to principal tenants who constructed shops and inducted sub-tenants. The owners obtained a decree for actual possession of the portions occupied by the principal tenants and symbolic possession of shops occupied by sub-tenants.

The Supreme Court upheld that distinction. It explained that delivery under Rule 36 remains symbolic vis-à-vis the person actually occupying the property who is not bound by the decree, but amounts to actual delivery as against the person bound by the decree. The executing court could not go beyond the decree and physically evict the sub-tenants.

Rule 36 does not protect every person found on the property; the question is whether the occupant is entitled to remain and is not bound by the decree to relinquish possession.

7. Legal Effect of Symbolic Possession

Symbolic possession is a recognised mode of execution, but its consequences require qualification.

A. Satisfaction of the Decree Against the Judgment-Debtor

Once delivery is properly effected under Rule 36, it operates as actual delivery in law against the person bound by the decree.

In Ratan Lal Jain, the Supreme Court stated that the rights of the person bound by the decree stand extinguished and that person is treated as removed from the property in the eye of law.

In Shew Bux Mohata v. Bengal Breweries Ltd., AIR 1961 SC 137, the decree-holders had accepted and acknowledged full delivery under Rule 35 while permitting the occupants to remain. The Supreme Court held that, having accepted the decree as fully executed, they could not seek a second execution for the same relief.

The result depends on valid delivery and the decree-holder’s acceptance; defective or incomplete execution is not automatically converted into satisfaction.

B. Attornment and Tenancy Rights

Rights concerning rent or attornment may pass to the decree-holder where the decree and the underlying contract or law so provide.

In Ratan Lal Jain, the lease deed specifically contemplated that, on determination of the principal lease, the buildings and tenancies would be handed over and that the owners could receive rent directly from sub-tenants. The Court applied those contractual terms.

Rule 36 does not, by itself, make every protected occupant a tenant of the decree-holder or automatically create a new tenancy.

C. Interruption of Adverse Possession

In Mamidi Venkata Satyanarayana Manikyala Rao v. Mandela Narasimhaswami, AIR 1966 SC 470, the Supreme Court held that symbolic delivery of joint possession effected under the relevant execution provisions interrupted the continuity of adverse possession.

That case concerned delivery under Order XXI Rule 96 in the context of joint possession, not Rule 36. It illustrates the possible limitation consequences of legally effective symbolic delivery, but should not be treated as a direct ruling that every delivery under Rule 36 automatically interrupts every adverse-possession claim.

8. Resistance by Third Parties and Transferees Pendente Lite

Order XXI Rules 97–101 govern resistance and third-party claims. Under Rule 97, the decree-holder may apply against resistance or obstruction; Rule 101 requires the executing court to decide relevant questions of right, title or interest instead of relegating the parties to a separate suit.

In Shreenath v. Rajesh, (1998) 4 SCC 543, the Supreme Court held that a third party claiming an independent right, including an independent tenancy, may raise an objection under Rule 97 and have it decided by the executing court before dispossession. The expression “any person” is wide enough to include a person who was not a party to the original suit.

Order XXI Rule 102: Transferees Pendente Lite

A different rule governs a transferee pendente lite. Rule 102 excludes the operation of Rules 98 and 100 in the case of resistance by a person to whom the judgment-debtor transferred the property after institution of the suit.

It reflects the doctrine of lis pendens under Section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882: the transfer is not void, but cannot prejudice the rights of other parties under the eventual decree, except with the court’s authority.

In Tahir V. Isani v. Madan Waman Chodankar, 2025 INSC 1044, the Supreme Court clarified that Rule 102 applies only where the person resisting execution derives the relevant property right from the judgment-debtor through a transfer made after institution of the suit. A person claiming through an independent third party is not automatically barred merely because that person acquired the property during the litigation.

The source of the occupant’s title and the date and nature of the transfer must therefore be examined; not every third-party occupant is automatically barred.

9. Composite Illustration

Suppose A obtains a decree for possession of a commercial building against B. B occupies the ground floor and refuses to leave; the decree awards A joint possession of the first floor with another co-sharer; and an independent tenant occupies a shop on the second floor under a right not affected by the decree.

The court may remove B and deliver actual possession of the ground floor under Rule 35(1), deliver joint possession of the first floor through the procedure in Rule 35(2), and deliver symbolic possession of the shop under Rule 36.

If B had transferred an interest in part of the property to D after institution of the suit, Rule 102 and Section 52 would have to be considered before recognising D’s objection.

10. Conclusion

Order 21 Rule 35 CPC governs actual delivery, joint possession and removal of obstacles, while Rule 36 provides symbolic delivery where an occupant is not bound to relinquish possession.

Read with Rules 97–102 and Section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act, these provisions balance enforcement of decrees with protection of genuine independent occupants.

Responsive Social Media Badges
Scroll to Top